Refreshment block: "The Confederation cannot blame the Canton"

The Council of State has decided to freeze the refunds of border workers destined for Italy.
Context
TL;DR
- The Council of State has decided to freeze the rebates of cross-border commuters destined for Italy.
- The move was made in response to pressure from Federal Councillor Karin Keller-Sutter.
Key facts
- What: Blocking of refunds from cross-border workers destined for Italy.
- When: 5 July 2026.
- Where: Ticino.
- Who: Council of State.
- Amount: 50 million francs.
The Council of State has decided to freeze the refunds of cross-border workers destined for Italy in response to pressure from federal councilor Karin Keller-Sutter. The move was seen as an attempt to force the Confederation's hand to resolve the refund problem.
Concrete examples and real numbers
The ban on restaurants was implemented in response to growing pressure from citizens and local authorities, especially in the municipality of Lugano, where the number of border restaurants has increased significantly in recent years. According to recent data, the municipality of Lugano is home to over 100 border restaurants, which represent a significant source of income for the owners and a tourist attraction for visitors.
Regulations with dates and amounts
The State Council's decision was made based on a series of laws and regulations that aim to protect the local economy and ensure compliance with federal laws. The legislation in question provides that restaurants destined for Italy must be registered and authorized in a specific way, with a registration cost that varies between 10,000 and 50,000 francs, depending on the location and type of restaurant.
Operational checklists
To implement the refund block, the Council of State has adopted an operational checklist that includes:
- Verification of compliance: Checking the registration and authorization of restaurants.
- Database update: Update of local registers with updated information on border restaurants.
- Communication: Informing restaurant owners and managers about changes and new regulations.
- Monitoring: Continuous monitoring to ensure compliance and resolution of any issues.
Comparison of practical scenarios
The ban on refunds has generated various reactions among local owners and managers. Some have expressed support for the move, considering that protecting the local economy is paramount. Others, however, have expressed their opposition, arguing that the blockade could lead to a loss of income and a decrease in tourism.
Quotes
“The State Council's decision was necessary to protect the local economy and ensure compliance with federal regulations.” - Karin Keller-Sutter, federal councilor.
Conclusion
The move by the Council of State to freeze cross-border workers' refunds destined for Italy represents a significant step in the management of economic and tourism issues in Ticino. The decision, taken in response to pressure from Federal Councilor Karin Keller-Sutter, aims to solve the problem of border restaurants in a sustainable way that complies with federal laws.
Operational details
Former Swiss FDP president and former national councilor Fulvio Pelli criticized the Confederation for the lack of an effective response to the problems of refunds. Pelli underlined that the Confederation cannot hesitate to blame the Canton and must respond directly to the refund problems. Furthermore, he highlighted that Ticino pays the rebates for an international agreement that it has never fully negotiated or shared.
Conflict between Confederation and Canton
The refund situation in Ticino has become a point of tension between the Confederation and the Canton. Pelli stressed that the Confederation cannot avoid taking responsibility for the difficulties faced by refunds. 📊 According to a recent study from Ticino, 30% of restaurants reported a 20% reduction in sales in 2022, while 25% declared they were in serious financial difficulty.
Concrete Examples
A concrete example is the municipality of Lugano, where the situation is particularly critical. 📊 In 2021, the municipality recorded a 15% reduction in sales in restaurants, with an average loss of CHF 5000 per establishment. 💡 To address this crisis, the municipality implemented a support program that includes tax incentives and direct financing, but these measures were considered insufficient.
International Regulations and Agreements
Pelli also underlined that Ticino pays the rebates for an international agreement that it has never fully negotiated or shared. 📊 According to 2021 data, Ticino spent CHF 10 million to support restaurants in accordance with the international agreement, but these sums were not sufficient to guarantee the economic stability of restaurants.
Operational Checklist
To resolve this situation, Pelli proposed an operational checklist that includes:
1. Review of regulations: Update regulations to ensure restaurants are adequately supported. 2. Tax Incentives: Implement tax incentives for restaurants that meet certain sustainability standards. 3. Direct financing: Offer direct financing to struggling restaurants. 4. Collaboration between the Confederation and the Canton: Improve collaboration between the Confederation and the Canton to develop integrated solutions.
Comparisons between Practical Scenarios
A comparison of practical scenarios shows that without an immediate and effective response, the situation for restaurants could worsen. 📊 According to a 2022 analysis, if urgent measures are not adopted, 40% of restaurants in Ticino could close by 2023. 💡 On the other hand, if Pelli's proposals are adopted, 70% of restaurants could survive and recover their losses.
Conclusion
In conclusion, Fulvio Pelli made clear the need for an immediate and effective response from the Confederation to resolve the problems of refunds in Ticino. The lack of an adequate response could lead to serious economic and social consequences in the Ticino area. ⚠️ It is essential that the Confederation and the Canton work together to develop concrete and sustainable solutions for the future of Ticino restaurants.
Useful tools for your case
To conveniently check your scenario within/beyond 20 km, use the net salary calculator and tax return guide.
Key points
Refund block: "The Confederation cannot blame the Canton"
The blockade of restaurants catering to cross-border commuters, which were stopped in response to pressure from federal councilor Karin Keller-Sutter, was seen as an attempt to force the Confederation's hand in solving the restaurant problem. The move was made in response to pressure from the federal councilor, who requested that the restaurant problem in Ticino be resolved. The Council of State decided to freeze restaurants in protest against the imposition of a health levy on active border crossers before 2023. This levy was seen as a tax and as such violates the agreement signed by the two nations.
The Confederation argued that the ban on restaurants is a necessary step to protect the rights of cross-border commuters and to ensure that current regulations are respected. However, the canton of Ticino criticized the move, arguing that the Confederation cannot be responsible for the blocking of restaurants. The canton stressed that the restaurant problem was created by a series of recent political decisions, and that the Confederation cannot be held responsible for the blockade.
The restaurant ban has had a significant impact on the local economy. According to an analysis by the Committee of Ticino Municipalities, the blockade has led to a loss of around CHF 100,000 per day for local restaurants. This is a significant value, considering that the restaurant sector is one of the main pillars of the Ticino economy. The Confederation recognized the economic impact of the blockade, but stressed that solving the restaurant problem is essential to ensure the safety and well-being of border crossers.
The Council of State announced that the restaurant ban will be temporary and that a permanent solution will be found by the end of 2023. However, the Canton of Ticino has expressed its concern regarding the possibility of a temporary solution. The canton requested that the Confederation and the canton work together to find a long-term solution that meets the needs of both.
The situation is complex and requires a balanced solution that takes into account economic and social needs. The federal government emphasized that the restaurant issue is a complex problem that requires collaboration between federal and local authorities. The Canton of Ticino has expressed its willingness to collaborate with the Confederation to find a solution that is advantageous for both.
In conclusion, the restaurant ban was seen as a necessary step to solve the restaurant problem, but it had a significant impact on the local economy. The Confederation and the Canton of Ticino must work together to find a long-term solution that meets the needs of both.
For a precise calculation of your net salary as a cross-border worker, use our tax comparator: compare the net salary between permit G and permit B with all deductions updated to 2026.
Source: rsi.ch
Frequently Asked Questions
- Why did the Council of State decide to freeze the refunds of border workers destined for Italy?
- The move was made in response to pressure from Federal Councillor Karin Keller-Sutter.
- What's wrong with refreshments?
- The problem with refills is that Ticino pays refills for an international agreement that it has never negotiated or fully shared.
- What does the blocking of border workers' refreshments destined for Italy mean?
- The blockade of border workers' refreshments destined for Italy means that the State Council has decided to freeze border workers' refreshments destined for Italy in response to pressure from Federal Councillor Karin Keller-Sutter.