Valais right and business oppose a minimum wage of CHF 22

The right wing and the Valais economy say no to CHF 22 an hour.
Context
TL;DR
- The right wing and the Valais economy say no to CHF 22 an hour.
- The popular vote is scheduled for November 29.
- The Grand Council rejected the text: 93 votes to 33.
- For agriculture, a threshold of CHF 18 an hour is indicated.
Key facts
- Subject → cantonal minimum wage
- General amount → CHF 22 per hour
- Agriculture → CHF 18 per hour
- Vote → November 29
- Grand Council decision → 93 votes to 33
- Valid signatures → 5.068
- Submission → September 2022
On November 29, the people of Valais will vote on the initiative by the left and the trade unions to introduce a cantonal minimum wage of CHF 22 per hour. The no campaign was launched by the right and the umbrella organizations of the Valais economy. According to opponents, the threshold puts jobs at risk and harms the vocational training of apprentices.
The opposing camp
Mathias Delaloye, president of the opposition committee, summarized the position by stating that all branches of the Valais economy are united against the minimum wage. The president of the Valais Chamber of Agriculture said that the proposal could concretely endanger employment. In his view, a yes vote could create not wage floors but wage ceilings. He also called the threshold a possible trap for apprentices, who could be pushed to interrupt their training in order to earn sooner and more.
Delaloye also criticized the two-tier model: CHF 18 per hour for agriculture and CHF 22 for other trades. In his view, this difference shows the inconsistency of the text and confirms that it should be the economy, not the state, that sets wages.
Caroline Melly-Basili, of the Centre du Valais romand, said that the proposal is not the miracle cure it is presented as. Vincent Pravato, president of the cantonal PLR, highlighted investments in vocational training, including continuing education, in companies, innovation and a strong social partnership. Julien Besson, of the UDCVR, added that a collective labor agreement (CCT) should not remain a mere document and should provide for sanctions, if necessary.
The institutional process
On May 6, the Valais Grand Council rejected the initiative by 93 votes to 33, following the opinion of the Council of State. The decision of the cantonal parliament therefore precedes the popular vote on November 29. The initiative had been submitted in September 2022 by a committee made up of left-wing parties and several trade unions, with 5.068 valid signatures, more than the 3.000 required.
Operational details
Two thresholds and a debate about sectors
The clearest technical feature of the proposal is the existence of two minimum pay rates, not just one. The text cited by RTS indicates CHF 22 an hour for other occupations and an exception at CHF 18 an hour for agriculture.
Comparison between agriculture and other occupations
| Sector indicated | Hourly threshold | Difference from CHF 22 |
|---|---|---|
| Agriculture | CHF 18 an hour | CHF 4 less |
| Other occupations | CHF 22 an hour | Comparison basis |
The calculation is straightforward: 22 minus 18 equals CHF 4 an hour. Compared with the general threshold, the agricultural one is equivalent to about 82% and is therefore about 18% lower, always on an hourly basis. This is a comparison between the two amounts specified in the proposal, not a forecast about employment or actual wages.
For Mathias Delaloye, the dual threshold is evidence of the initiative's inconsistency. His objection concerns not only the amount of CHF 22, but also the principle that it would be the economy, and not the state, that sets wages. The structure of the proposal thus becomes one of the central points of the campaign against it.
Seasonality, mountain regions and part-time work
The economic organizations cited by the source add a problem of uniform implementation. François Jud, of the Valais Commercial Union, highlighted the difficulty of standardizing different practices and recalled the reality of numerous employees working in mountain regions, particularly in tourism. Florian Piasenta, for Gastrovalais, clarified that the association is not opposed to an increase in wages, but asks that seasonality, weekends and people who wish to work part-time be taken into account.
These positions shift the comparison from the hourly amount alone to the conditions under which the work is performed. Politically, Vincent Pravato calls for vocational training, investment, innovation and social partnership; Julien Besson, on the other hand, insists that a CCT should be able to be accompanied by sanctions. The source does not specify whether these instruments are presented as formal alternatives to the minimum wage or as parallel measures.
Key points
The popular vote remains to be held
From the Grand Council decision to the ballot box
The source distinguishes between two stages that do not have the same significance. On May 6, the Valais Grand Council expressed an opposing position by 93 votes to 33, following the view of the Council of State. On November 29, it will instead be the people of Valais who will have their say. The Grand Council vote is therefore not presented as the definitive outcome of the initiative, and the source does not report any result of the popular vote.
The preceding process is also documented only in its essential elements. In September 2022, the committee formed by left-wing parties and several trade unions submitted 5.068 valid signatures, exceeding the 3.000 required. The article also points to a previous feature devoted to the arguments of the left and the trade unions, whose title claims that in Valais 15.000 employees work at 100% without being able to live on their salary. However, the text on the no campaign does not develop that figure or present a comparison between the two positions.
The limits of the available data
The source reports concerns about employment and apprenticeships, but does not provide a measurement of the number of jobs involved, the apprentices affected or the effects on the different sectors. Nor does it indicate current salaries, net pay or a monthly calculation based on the hourly thresholds.
For those seeking the effect on their pay packet, the text therefore leaves out AVS/AHV and LPP/BVG deductions, LAMal/KVG premiums, direct federal tax and VAT. It does not cite analyses by SECO or FSO/BFS, nor a comparison between cantons or a measure of the cost of living. The report thus documents the political and economic positions and the voting timetable, but does not make it possible to automatically convert CHF 22 per hour into a net amount.
A separate salary calculation is available at salary/tax calculator.
Source: rts.ch
Frequently Asked Questions
- What is the subject of the vote on November 29?
- The people of Valais will vote on the initiative by the left and the trade unions to introduce a cantonal minimum wage set at CHF 22 per hour.
- What decision did the Grand Council make regarding the initiative?
- The Valais Grand Council rejected the proposal on 6 May by 93 votes to 33, following the opinion of the Council of State.
- What are the two time thresholds set out in the proposal?
- The text indicates a general threshold of CHF 22 per hour for other occupations and a specific threshold of CHF 18 per hour for agriculture.
- When was the initiative filed and how many valid signatures did it collect?
- The initiative was submitted in September 2022 by a committee of left-wing parties and trade unions, collecting 5.068 valid signatures, exceeding the 3.000 required.