Minimum wage in Valais: vote on November 29 on CHF 22

On November 29, the people of Valais will vote on the cantonal popular initiative for a statutory minimum wage.
Context
TL;DR
- 15'000 full-time employees cannot make a living from their wages
- The vote on the minimum wage is set for November 29
- The proposal provides for a gross hourly wage of CHF 22
- Parliament rejected it by 93 votes to 33
Key facts
- Subject → cantonal statutory minimum wage
- Amount → CHF 22 gross per hour
- Vote → November 29
- Parliament → 93 to 33, with no counterproposal
- Rules → agricultural exemption possible at CHF 18; apprentices and some internships excluded
On November 29, the people of Valais will vote on the cantonal popular initiative for a statutory minimum wage. The text was submitted in September 2022 and proposes CHF 22 gross per hour. For agriculture, an exemption at CHF 18 gross per hour is possible. Apprentices and some internships are excluded; the text also provides for the possibility of exceptions within the framework of occupational integration measures. In the event of an increase in the Swiss Consumer Price Index, the text provides for the minimum wage to be indexed.
The campaign and the political front
The campaign in favor brings together left-wing parties, trade unions and associations. For this coalition, what is at stake concerns equality, dignity and social justice. Blaise Carron, secretary general of Unia, indicated at a press conference held on Tuesday in Sion that in Valais around 15'000 people work full time without being able to live on their wages. He added that the so-called «working poor» are mostly women. Carron was also interviewed on the RTS 12h30 programme.
The proponents argue that raising the lowest wages would strengthen purchasing power and the local economy. Emmanuel Amoos, Socialist National Councillor, linked the proposal to the situation of people who work but still have to rely on social assistance to make ends meet. Léonard Dorsaz, a Green MP, argued that a minimum wage would improve the financial situation of the lowest-paid workers and consequently reduce reliance on state aid.
The vote after Parliament's rejection
In the May session, the Valais Parliament rejected the initiative by 93 votes to 33, without presenting a counterproposal. The Council of State is also opposed. According to the Council of State, the measure would threaten certain sectors of the Valais economy, including agriculture and retail trade in the side valleys.
Supporters instead cite the Cantons of Geneva and Neuchâtel, which have already introduced a minimum wage, and assert that where it has been adopted, the labour market has been revitalized. Francine Zufferey, president of the Valais Trade Union Federation, rejects a competitiveness model based on low wages and points to quality, skills, innovation and service. Vincent Riesen, director of the Valais Chamber of Commerce, warns, however, that the minimum could risk becoming a maximum: in his assessment, the progression of collective agreements could come to a standstill and broader working conditions would take a back seat.
Operational details
The practical comparison between threshold and consequences
The proposal is not limited to specifying a figure. Its framework distinguishes categories, provides for a sectoral exemption, excludes certain pathways, and links the amount to the price index. To assess the effects without confusing the rule with the political promise, it is useful to separate what the text establishes from what supporters and opponents predict.
The differences provided for in the text
| Situation indicated | Effect to consider |
|---|---|
| Remuneration provided for by the initiative | CHF 22 gross per hour |
| Agriculture | Possible exemption at CHF 18 gross per hour |
| Apprentices and certain internships | Excluded |
| Vocational integration | Possible exceptions |
| Swiss Consumer Price Index | Indexation if it increases |
For an employee with a low wage, the reference point would be the gross hourly wage. However, the figure of CHF 22 should not be applied indiscriminately: agriculture may fall under the CHF 18 exemption, while apprentices and certain internships are outside the scheme. Vocational integration measures may in turn provide for exceptions. These elements make the impact differ depending on the position held, without the text indicating equal treatment for every employment relationship.
Indexation introduces a second element to monitor. The text links it to an increase in the Swiss Consumer Price Index. The analysis must therefore distinguish the initial amount from any potential adjustment, without turning indexation into an already calculated figure.
Two economic scenarios
The committee supporting the proposal views the threshold as a tool to improve the financial situation of those earning less, limit reliance on state aid, strengthen purchasing power and support the local economy. The reference to Geneva and Neuchâtel serves to support the argument that the introduction of a minimum wage would have revitalized the labor market. The comparison remains qualitative: the source mentions the revival, but does not compare figures.
The Council of State emphasizes the risks for agriculture and retail trade in the side valleys. Vincent Riesen's position adds a possible effect on the relationship between the minimum and collective bargaining: if the threshold were to become the maximum wage in practice, the progression of collective agreements could be reduced until it disappeared, while general working conditions would lose ground. This is a forecast expressed by opponents, not an outcome already observed in Valais.
The vote should therefore be read on two levels: the proposed gross threshold and the associated labor-market model. The source contrasts dignity, purchasing power and public aid with sectoral competitiveness and collective bargaining.
Key points
What to check before November 29
The date to follow is November 29, but the CHF 22 threshold is still part of the text submitted to the public. For those working in Valais, the practical check must start from their own category rather than from an undifferentiated reading of the amount.
A four-step check
1. Identify the employment situation. The text distinguishes the agricultural sector, for which it allows a possible derogation, from apprentices and certain internships, which are excluded. Professional integration measures may have exceptions. 2. Separate gross and net. The amount indicated by the initiative is CHF 22 gross per hour; in the agricultural sector, the possible derogation reference is CHF 18 gross per hour. The comparison must be made with the gross hourly figure, without turning the data into a promise about what would remain in the paycheck. 3. Check for a derogation or exclusion. An apprentice or a person in one of the excluded internships should not be treated as a covered worker; likewise, an integration measure may fall within the exceptions provided for. The text recognizes these differences, so it is not correct to automatically apply the threshold to every case. 4. Follow indexation. The text links the minimum wage to the Swiss Consumer Price Index when the latter increases. The initial amount and its possible evolution must therefore be kept distinct.
For companies and workers
To analyze the dossier concretely, it is advisable to put the effects declared by the two sides in two columns. On the one hand, the yes committee indicates greater purchasing power, support for the local economy and less reliance on state aid. On the other, the Council of State points to agriculture and retail trade in the side valleys, while the Valais Chamber of Commerce highlights the risk that the minimum could become a maximum and that the progression of collective agreements could come to a halt.
This distinction avoids two errors. The first is presenting CHF 22 as an amount that can already be applied: the decision still rests with the public. The second is presenting an economic effect as certain when the source formulates it as a forecast or political argument. The reference to Geneva and Neuchâtel should also be read for what it is: an element put forward by the proponents to support the argument that the labor market would be revitalized.
After the vote, observe the relationship between the amount, derogations, exclusions and indexation. These elements show whether the proposal is understood as wage protection or as a risk for collective bargaining and certain sectors. To compare remuneration in francs with the impact on income, use the calcolatore stipendio e imposte
Source: rts.ch
Frequently Asked Questions
- When will the vote on the minimum wage in Valais take place?
- The vote on the cantonal statutory minimum wage in Valais is set for November 29. The people of Valais will vote on this cantonal popular initiative filed in September 2022, which proposes a gross amount of CHF 22 per hour. At the May session, the Valais Parliament rejected the initiative by 93 votes to 33, without presenting a counterproposal, and the Council of State also expressed its opposition.
- What are the main exceptions provided for in the minimum wage proposal?
- The filed text provides for some specific exceptions and exemptions. With regard to agriculture, it establishes the possibility of an exemption at CHF 18 gross per hour. Apprentices and some internships, on the other hand, are expressly excluded from its scope. In addition, the text provides for the possibility of specific exceptions within the framework of vocational integration measures.
- What positions do supporters and opponents of the measure take?
- The camp in favor, which brings together left-wing parties, trade unions and associations, argues that the measure would promote equality, dignity and social justice, as well as strengthen purchasing power and the local economy, citing the example of Geneva and Neuchâtel. Conversely, the Council of State fears repercussions for sectors such as agriculture and retail trade in the side valleys, while the Valais Chamber of Commerce warns that the minimum could turn into a maximum, blocking the progression of collective agreements.