Sion: the Maison de la garde opens for emergencies

Illustration generated for this article

Since September 1, Sion Hospital has opened a Maison de la garde to relieve pressure on the emergency department, described as overcrowded. The new facility is intended for non-life-threatening cases and operates every day from 18 to 22, the period identified as the busiest.

Context

TL;DR

  • From September 1, Maison de la garde at Sion hospital
  • 80 doctors cover 18-22, seven days a week
  • The service handles non-life-threatening cases
  • Survey: 22 doctors opposed out of 80

Key facts

  • Facility → Maison de la garde at Sion Hospital
  • Hours → 18-22, seven days a week
  • Doctors → 80 general practitioners with practices between Martigny and Sierre
  • Model → Viège and Riaz; pilot project in Sion in 2024
  • Survey → 22 opposed, 38 in favour, 20 undecided

Since September 1, Sion Hospital has opened a Maison de la garde to relieve pressure on the emergency department, described as overcrowded. The new facility is intended for non-life-threatening cases and operates every day from 18 to 22, the period identified as the busiest.

Staffing the service are 80 general practitioners with practices between Martigny and Sierre. Their presence is organized seven days a week in the hospital facility, a few steps from the emergency department. The location is intended to simplify coordination among the professionals and enable rapid care for less serious cases.

The four evening hours coincide with the period identified as the busiest for emergency cases. The premises were placed in the immediate vicinity precisely to maintain operational contact between the general practitioners and the emergency-service professionals.

A separate circuit alongside the emergency department

The system forms part of the triage already used in the emergency department: the severity of the condition determines priority. Life-threatening emergencies go first, while more minor cases can wait. The Maison de la garde therefore offers a point close to the emergency department for managing cases that do not require the same priority.

Florence Sierro, a general practitioner, described the operational advantage of the new setup to RTS: when the waiting room fills up, the possibility of redirecting some patients and getting them seen more quickly is experienced as rewarding and satisfying for everyone. The new arrangement also appears to ease the workload of the emergency staff in Sion.

The project was launched by the Canton of Valais, Hôpital du Valais and Société médicale du Valais. The model draws on experiences already operating at the hospital in Viège, in Upper Valais, and at Riaz Hospital, in the Canton of Fribourg. A pilot project carried out in Sion in 2024 had confirmed its relevance. The new facility thus brings an organizational model already tested elsewhere to the cantonal capital.

Operational details

A balance divided between organization and workload

The most delicate point does not concern the principle of triage, but the distribution of shifts among the participating general practitioners. For each general practitioner, the source indicates four or five shifts per year. The experience reported by Florence Sierro is positive because the hospital schedule makes it possible to know in advance when one starts and finishes, with simpler family planning than before.

This same assessment is not shared by everyone. At the end of September, Le Nouvelliste reported discontent among the general practitioners called upon to participate. The online survey cited by the newspaper divides the group into 38 in favor, 22 opposed, and 20 doctors who did not wish to express an opinion. The figures therefore show non-unanimous support, while the service involves the entire group of doctors called upon to cover the duty.

Two levels of organization

The criticisms gathered by RTS concern above all the speed of the launch. Some doctors complained that they had received the dates from one day to the next, having to fit the new commitment in with the rest of their duties. One general practitioner spoke of overload and the difficulty of organizing herself with her children; family management is therefore a concrete part of the assessment of the new model. The difficulty of coordinating commitments finds a practical link in resource asilo nido.

Table 1: Aspect
AspectReported data
Hospital duty18-22, seven days a week
Indicated frequencyfour or five shifts per year
Planned alternativecity on-call duty and practice coverage 07-22
Survey opinions38 in favor, 22 opposed, 20 did not express an opinion

The table highlights the difference between a hospital shift concentrated during the busiest hours and practice coverage that spans a broader time period. The model can therefore improve predictability for some doctors, but requires calendar management that others have judged too rapid or burdensome. The comparison remains anchored in hours, organization, and workload.

Recommended tools

For an updated estimate, use the net salary calculator and the CHF-EUR exchange comparator.

Useful tools to protect your net income

To reduce FX leakage, compare CHF-EUR exchange options and banks for cross-border workers.

Key points

What doctors and patients need to consider

For the doctor involved, the operational framework described by the source follows a clear sequence. The shift at the Maison de la garde of Sion hospital runs from 18 to 22, every day. The facility handles non-life-threatening cases and is located next to the emergency department, so as to facilitate coordination with emergency-room staff.

Anyone who does not intend to take an on-call shift at the hospital is not left, as Pierre Arnold recalled, without an alternative: they can exchange that shift for a city on-call shift and ensure their presence in their own practice from 07 to 22. That choice, however, does not amount to an exemption. If the doctor also refuses the exchange, the president of the SMVS on-call committee indicates a possible sanctions process: first a warning, then a fine and, as a last resort, a report to the Canton. The Canton may decide to temporarily suspend the right to practice.

For those who come to the emergency department

For the patient, the practical point is the prioritization criterion. Life-threatening emergencies remain first; less serious cases may be directed to the Maison de la garde, where its proximity to the emergency department allows for rapid care and coordination among professionals. The service also operates outside weekdays, because coverage is provided seven days a week.

For doctors' families, the experience reported by Florence Sierro points to one specific advantage: knowing the start and end of the shift in advance makes it possible to organize. This factor must be weighed against reports of overload and the difficulty of reconciling on-call duty with children, which emerged among the less satisfied doctors.

The project does not change the clinical priority applied in the emergency department: it changes the way non-life-threatening cases are handled and general practitioners' work is distributed during the busiest period. To learn more about the available healthcare tools, consult LAMal/cassa malati. To estimate the effect of any shifts on personal income, use calcolatore stipendio.

Source: rts.ch

Frequently Asked Questions
What is the Maison de la garde and how does it work?
La Maison de la garde is a facility at Sion Hospital intended to handle non-life-threatening cases in order to relieve the emergency department. It operates every day, seven days a week, from 18 to 22, which has been identified as the busiest period for emergencies. The service is provided by 80 general practitioners with practices between Martigny and Sierre, and the facility is strategically located just a few steps from the emergency service for rapid coordination.
What are the alternatives for general practitioners?
Doctors who do not intend to work on call at the hospital may exchange the shift for a city on-call shift and ensure that they remain at their own practice from 07 to 22. If they refuse both options, the president of the SMVS on-call commission has indicated a sanctioning procedure involving a warning, a fine and, as a last resort, a report to the Canton, which may decide on a provisional suspension of the right to practise.
How does this new triage system affect life-threatening emergencies?
The system does not change the clinical priority applied in the emergency department: life-threatening emergencies retain absolute priority. Patients with less serious cases are directed to the Maison de la garde, where proximity to the emergency department enables rapid care and effective coordination between general practitioners and emergency department staff, improving the efficiency of the waiting room.

Related articles