Motion States: organizers pay safety costs

Swiss demonstration with police forces in the foreground

The States approve the motion 24-18 with 3 abstentions: the Federal Council will have to prepare a legal basis to make the organizers pay the costs of intervention and security of the demonstrations, after the riots of October 11 in Bern.

Context

TL;DR

  • The states approve the motion by 24 votes to 18
  • Three abstentions accompany the vote
  • The Federal Council will have to prepare a legal basis
  • The proposal covers intervention costs and safety

Key facts

  • Location → Bern
  • Vote → 24 votes to 18, with 3 abstentions
  • Mandate → The Federal Council must develop a legal basis
  • Costs → All or part of the intervention and safety costs
  • Proposer → Sidney Kamerzin (Centre/VS)
  • Demonstration mentioned → 11 October in Bern

The vote in Bern

In Bern, the Council of States approved with 24 votes against 18 and 3 abstentions a motion that opens up the possibility of charging the organizers for the costs caused by serious disturbances and violent acts during the demonstrations. The Nazionale had already expressed itself favorably; the passage to the States therefore completes the parliamentary support for the request, which now passes to the Federal Council for the legislative work indicated in the text.

The motion tasks the Federal Council with developing a legal basis. The objective is to allow public communities to collect all or part of the costs of the intervention and the measures necessary to guarantee its safety from the organizers of protests and demonstrations. The source does not yet describe a collection procedure, nor does it indicate amounts or a date of application: the announced step is the preparation of the legal basis.

Because the proposal reached Parliament

The text was presented by national councilor Sidney Kamerzin (Centre/VS). The motivation recalls several recent demonstrations, in particular that of October 11th in Bern, which resulted in violence against the population at the hands of violent extremists. According to the motion, prevention and protection have made important measures by the police necessary.

Daniel Jositsch (Independent/ZH) supported the request, stating: «It is not up to the community to bear the costs associated with these safety measures». In his speech he also mentioned a situation of impunity which, he said, he had personally observed in the streets of Zurich.

The vote did not end the institutional debate. Carlo Sommaruga (PS/GE) contested the motion for the possible conflict with the principle of subsidiarity and for the limits it could impose on the autonomy of the cantons. Mathias Zopfi (Greens/GL) added that the text is formulated in too broad terms and could concern all demonstrations, including those on May 1st. Beat Jans, justice minister, reiterated the same objection. The states' vote therefore concerns the mandate of the Federal Council, not a figure already established for individual events.

Operational details

What can change

The practical point of the motion is the shifting of the possible cost: in the presence of serious disorders and violent acts, a public community could ask the organizers for all or part of the expenses incurred for the intervention and security. In the text, these expenses are described as measures that required law enforcement intervention; the proposal aims to create the possibility of recovering them from those who organize the protest or demonstration. There are no amounts, thresholds, attribution criteria or a formula for calculating the bill. These elements will therefore have to be clarified by the legal basis that the Federal Council is responsible for developing.

A national rule, cantonal competences

For the Cantons, the issue has two distinct levels. The regulation of the right to demonstrate remains a cantonal responsibility, and some Cantons have already issued regulations on the matter. However, favorable senators argue that a national cost rule would reduce current disparities and harmonize existing regulations. The change, if translated into a legal basis, would therefore not cancel the role of the Cantons described in the source; would add a national framework on cost recovery.

The opposite position warns against the opposite effect. Carlo Sommaruga and Mathias Zopfi recalled the principle of subsidiarity and cantonal autonomy. Zopfi noted that the broad wording of the motion could also include demonstrations such as those on May Day. Beat Jans argued that public order during demonstrations falls within cantonal police sovereignty and that the Confederation should not determine which authorities' costs can be passed on to the organisers.

For those living in Switzerland, the concrete impact is therefore not an already fixed amount, but the possible change of rule between the organization of an event and public costs. If the legal basis is to be developed, at least three elements will need to be read: which events fall under serious disturbances, what costs can be requested and how the national rule coordinates with existing cantonal regulations. The source does not yet indicate the answers. A separate in-depth analysis on the cost of living in Switzerland does not replace this verification, but helps to keep the topic of public expenditure separate from that of the personal budget.

Useful tools to maximize the net

To reduce gear loss, compare the CHF-EUR exchange rate and banks for cross-border workers.

Key points

How to follow the dossier

To follow developments without confusing the vote with a rule that is already applicable, the operational process is divided into four steps:

1. Verify the text and the mandate received by the Federal Council: the source says that it must draw up a legal basis, but does not specify a deadline. 2. Wait for the recoverable costs to be defined, because the motion refers to all or part of the intervention and security costs without setting amounts or criteria. 3. Check the relationship with the Cantons, which remain responsible for regulating the right to demonstrate and maintaining public order. 4. Verify how demonstrations falling within the broad wording referred to in the debate will be treated, including those on May Day.

What to note when the legal basis arrives

Anyone organizing a protest or demonstration should look for four answers in the future text: which authority may request payment; under what conditions serious disturbances or violent acts are involved; which items are included in the intervention and security costs; whether the request may concern the full amount or only part of it. These questions are drawn directly from the mandate described in the source. Until they are clarified, the motion does not make it possible to calculate a specific charge.

Public authorities will also have to read the future rules together with the Cantonal provisions already in existence. The source reports, in fact, that some Cantons have already enacted rules in this area, while Justice Minister Beat Jans defended Cantonal sovereignty in police matters. Comparing the two levels will help determine whether the new legal basis will standardize the costs or leave room for differences in application.

The source does not specify a deadline for the Federal Council's work and does not indicate the forms, documents or authorities responsible for collection. For this reason, the useful check consists of comparing the future text with three points already established: the nature of the costs, the seriousness of the disturbances and the role of the Cantons. If one of these elements remains absent, it will not be possible to reconstruct from the vote alone what bill may be requested.

For a personal check on a different area, you can consult tax return. For a separate reading of your personal budget, use salary calculator.

Source: tio.ch

Frequently Asked Questions
What was the vote of the States on the motion?
The States approved the motion by 24 votes to 18, with 3 abstentions. The vote sent the Federal Council to prepare a legal basis that allows public authorities to collect from the organizers all or part of the intervention costs and measures necessary to ensure safety during the demonstrations.
Who filed the motion and what event is it referring to?
The motion was filed by National Councillor Sidney Kamerzin (Centre/VS). It refers to the demonstration of 11 October last in Bern, which resulted in violence against the population at the hands of violent extremists, which required important measures by law enforcement.
What still needs to be defined by the legal basis that the Federal Council will have to elaborate?
The legal basis will have to establish which events fall under the “serious disturbances” or violent acts, which items include the costs of intervention and security, and how the national rule will be coordinated with the already existing cantonal rules on the right to demonstrate and on the maintenance of public order. Without these details it will not be possible to calculate a concrete charge.

Related articles