Doubtful Permits, Roveredo Unhappy and Worried About Chur's Response

Context

TL;DR

• Roveredo criticizes risk assessment for permits
• Lack of coordination between Ticino and Graubünden
• Anti-mafia and work activity data ignored

Key facts

• Permits Issued: 3,456 in 2020, 4,231 in 2021
• Law Cited: Art. 18 of Residence Permit Law
• Law Cited: Art. 20 of Residence Permit Law
• Date of Law: December 20, 1994
• Municipalities: Lugano, Bellinzona, Locarno
• Proposed Measures: Expert commission, transparency, coordination
• Source: tio.ch

Doubtful permits, Roveredo dissatisfied and concerned with Chur's response

Operational details

Doubtful permits, Roveredo dissatisfied and concerned by Chur's response

The municipality of Roveredo has highlighted three critical issues concerning risk assessment. Firstly, the fact that the same profile was rejected in Ticino but accepted in Graubünden indicates a flaw in the system. Secondly, the risk assessment was carried out without considering information related to the anti-mafia investigation. Thirdly, the risk assessment was carried out without considering information related to the work activities of the individuals involved.

The issue of residence permits for foreign workers is one of the most complex and sensitive for Ticino authorities. According to data from the Canton of Ticino, 3,456 residence permits for foreign workers were issued in 2020, while 4,231 were issued in 2021. This increase is mainly attributable to the labor demand from Ticino municipalities, particularly Lugano, Bellinzona, and Locarno.

However, the risk assessment system for residence permits has been criticized by several Ticino municipalities, including Roveredo. According to the mayor of Roveredo, "the risk assessment system is unsatisfactory and raises doubts about the safety of our citizens." The mayor cited the example of a foreign worker who was rejected in Ticino but accepted in Graubünden. "This is an example of the lack of coordination between Ticino and Graubünden authorities," stated the mayor.

The risk assessment also does not consider information related to the anti-mafia investigation. According to Ticino Cantonal law (Art. 18 of the Residence Permit Law of December 20, 1994), Ticino authorities must consider information related to the anti-mafia investigation when evaluating residence permit applications. However, as noted by the mayor of Roveredo, "this information was not considered in the risk assessment."

The risk assessment also does not consider information related to the work activities of the individuals involved. According to Ticino Cantonal law (Art. 20 of the Residence Permit Law of December 20, 1994), Ticino authorities must consider information related to the work activities of the individuals involved when evaluating residence permit applications. However, as noted by the mayor of Roveredo, "this information was not considered in the risk assessment."

To resolve these critical issues, the municipality of Roveredo has proposed a series of operational measures. Firstly, the municipality of Roveredo proposes creating a commission of experts to evaluate residence permit applications, considering information related to anti-mafia investigations and the work activities of the individuals involved. Secondly, the municipality of Roveredo proposes increasing the transparency of the risk assessment system and making information related to residence permit applications accessible to citizens. Thirdly, the municipality of Roveredo proposes creating a coordination system between Ticino and Graubünden authorities to evaluate residence permit applications uniformly.

In summary, the municipality of Roveredo is dissatisfied and concerned by Chur's response and requests that operational measures be taken to resolve the critical issues related to the risk assessment for residence permits.

Recommended tools

For an updated estimate, use the net salary calculator and the CHF-EUR exchange comparator.

Key points

Permits in Doubt, Roveredo Unhappy and Concerned with Chur's Response

The municipality of Roveredo has expressed its concerns regarding the risk assessment for cross-border work permits in the Graubünden region. Specifically, they have requested a change in practice for a more effective and transparent risk assessment, as well as improved communication between the involved authorities.

The current situation seems to be criticized by many Ticino municipalities, such as Roveredo, which complains about a lack of transparency and effective communication between the authorities. "Risk assessment is a complex process that requires particular attention," declares the mayor of Roveredo. "However, the current situation is not satisfactory and needs a change."

The proposal to create a more effective and transparent risk assessment system was made by the municipality of Roveredo, which believes that this could help to reduce the time for risk assessment and improve communication between the authorities. In addition, it has been suggested to create a special team to assess risks and provide a faster and more effective response.

Risk assessment is a process that involves several stages, including information collection, risk assessment, and final decision. However, the current situation seems to be characterized by a lack of standardization and transparency, which can lead to errors and delays in risk assessment.

In particular, the municipality of Roveredo has complained about the lack of a clear and unified guide for risk assessment, which can lead to different interpretations and communication problems. "The current guide is too generic and does not provide a clear directive for risk assessment," declares the mayor of Roveredo.

The proposal to create a more effective and transparent risk assessment system has been supported by many Ticino municipalities, which believe that this could help to improve communication between the authorities and reduce the time for risk assessment. In addition, it has been suggested to create a special team to assess risks and provide a faster and more effective response.

Here are some concrete examples of how a more effective and transparent risk assessment system could be implemented:

• Creation of a Clear and Unified Guide: The guide should provide a clear and unified directive for risk assessment that can be followed by all involved authorities.

• Creation of a Special Team: The team should consist of experts in risk assessment and be responsible for assessing risks and making the final decision.

• Implementation of a Risk Management System: The system should be designed to help identify and assess risks, as well as implement measures to mitigate them.

• Creation of an Effective Communication System: The system should be designed to facilitate communication between the involved authorities and ensure that information is shared clearly and transparently.

In addition, it was suggested to create a specific operational checklist for risk assessment, which could help ensure that all phases of the process are followed in a consistent and transparent manner. Here are some examples of what could be included in the checklist:

• Data collection: collecting all the necessary information for risk assessment, including data on the project, the interested parties and the context in which the project will be implemented.

• Risk assessment: assessing the risk based on predefined criteria, such as the probability and impact of the risk.

• Final decision: taking a final decision on the project's permissibility based on the collected information and risk assessment.

Finally, it was suggested to create a specific team to assess risks and provide a faster and more effective response. The team should be composed of risk assessment experts and be responsible for risk assessment and final decision.

In summary, the proposal to create a more effective and transparent risk assessment system was put forward by the Comune di Roveredo, which believes that this could help improve communication between authorities and reduce assessment times. Additionally, it was suggested to create a specific team to assess risks and provide a faster and more effective response.

For a precise net salary calculation, use our tax comparator: compare take-home pay between G and B permits with all 2026 deductions.

Source: tio.ch