Cross-border workers: entry tax, tax rebates and double taxation

Switzerland is introducing an entry tax of up to 4 thousand francs for employees and self-employed workers. There is discussion of 900 million annually for the unemployed, and there is a risk of 120 million for border municipalities.
Context
TL;DR
- Entry tax of up to 4 thousand francs for employees and self-employed workers
- Switzerland votes against 900 million annually for cross-border workers
- The roundtable on health tax and double taxation was on September 17
- 120 million at risk for border municipalities
Key facts
- Entry tax → up to 4 thousand francs
- Allowance for unemployed cross-border workers → 900 million francs
- Interministerial roundtable → September 17
- Average salary in Switzerland → 5.500 francs more in one year
- Border municipalities → 120 million at risk
- Legacy cross-border workers → data transmitted for the first time
Up to 4 thousand francs for employees and self-employed workers: this is the item that opens the page on cross-border workers. The opening headline asks who pays it, without adding any further answer in the available material. Alongside this item is Switzerland's no to the 900 million francs per year intended for cross-border workers.
From health tax to tax rebates
The same roundup lists a tax bonus for those who spend in Ticino and, on another level, the interministerial roundtable of September 17 devoted to health tax, double taxation and status. The sequence thus connects workers, taxation and relations between Italy and Switzerland, but leaves the individual headlines distinct.
The transfers section concerns border municipalities: the decree on the funds due to the administrations appears to have been signed. The page places alongside this news the item on the allowance for unemployed cross-border workers, described as a sum of 900 million charged to Switzerland, with the clarification that Switzerland can say no. The list also includes the risk of 120 million for municipalities bordering Switzerland.
Regarding the health tax, the headlines record a conflict between the Ticino government, the Swiss government, Regione Lombardia, and Italian and Swiss trade unions. One speaks of a possible halt to refunds; another calls the stoppage a violation of the agreements. After 912 days, the unions are still attacking and maintain that the health tax is a tax, not a contribution.
“The health tax is a tax, not a contribution”
The salary-related thread completes the picture. Pre-filled tax returns allegedly revealed protected data about cross-border workers' salaries, with accusations of privacy violations and demands for compensation. Another headline reports 5.500 francs more in one year for the average salary in Switzerland, approaching 100 thousand. Finally, the section on legacy cross-border workers mentions an error in the data, an Irpef alert and the transmission of that data for the first time.
Operational details
For a cross-border worker who works in the Canton of Ticino, the first practical distinction is between the income-tax line and the political debate over tax rebates. Tax on employment income is withheld at source in Switzerland. Italy avoids double taxation through the tax credit in section CE of form 730. This mechanism alone is not equivalent to a decision on the health tax.
Dates and categories that change the reading
The New Cross-Border Workers Agreement was signed on 23 December 2020 and has been in force since 1 January 2024. The distinction between old and new cross-border workers changes the tax-free allowance:
| Item | Verified rule |
|---|---|
| Old cross-border workers | Already in that category before 17 July 2023; Old cross-border workers remain taxed only in Switzerland (Art. 9 of the 2020 Agreement). Old cross-border workers remain taxed only in Switzerland (Art. 9 of the 2020 Agreement). |
| New cross-border workers | The €10,000 threshold in Article 4 of Italian Law No. 83/2023 applies exclusively to employment income earned continuously and exclusively by Italian residents in a foreign border area or neighbouring country, as referred to in Article 1(175) of Law No. 147/2013; it is neither a general allowance nor an exemption from Swiss withholding tax. |
The Convention on double taxation between Italy and Switzerland dates from 9 March 1976, and Switzerland is not an EU/EEA member. These are reference points that help avoid confusing the tax reference with the rest of the issues that appear in the overview.
The cross-border worker must also keep the G permit, AVS, LPP and LAMal separate: they are distinct matters from the calculation of withholding tax, the health tax and tax rebates. The tax aspect must then be checked in tax return, while AVS and LPP and LAMal do not replace checking the income tax assessment. This separation prevents every item in the Italy-Switzerland relationship from being read as if it were a deduction from the salary.
Key points
Four checks before doing the math
The figure of up to 4mila francs appears in the headline as an entry tax for employees and self-employed workers. It must therefore not automatically be turned into a personal withholding: the headline specifically raises the question of who pays it. The verification must start from the nature of the item, not only from the amount.
1. Start from July 17, 2023. Anyone who was already a cross-border worker before that date belongs to the group of old cross-border workers; Old cross-border workers remain taxed only in Switzerland (Art. 9 of the 2020 Agreement). For The Article 9 transitional regime applies only to workers who meet the Agreement’s definition and worked in Graubünden, Ticino or Valais between 31 December 2018 and 17 July 2023; covered employment income is taxable exclusively in Switzerland. The ordinary regime applies in other cases, with Italian taxation and credit for Swiss tax where applicable. The €10,000 in Article 4 of Law 83/2023 is only the income limit referred to in Article 1(175) of Law 147/2013, not a general allowance. FTA factsheet · Agreement, Article 9 · Normattiva, Article 4.
2. If the doubt concerns employment income, separate the withholding tax deducted in Switzerland from the tax credit in section CE of the 730. Do not add the two items together as if they were the same tax.
3. If the health tax appears, treat it as a question separate from double taxation and from refunds. The headlines in the roundup in fact show a discussion about its nature, alternatively described as a tax or contribution, and a conflict over the blocking of transfers.
4. If the check concerns the cross-border-worker headline, use the reference to Permit G/B without confusing it with the tax calculation. If instead you are reading a salary figure, consider the extra 5.500 francs as a figure referring to the average salary in Switzerland, not as an automatic increase in your payslip.
This sequence makes it possible to distinguish status, income, healthcare and transfers without attributing to the individual worker figures that the source refers to categories or averages. To turn the salary figure into an estimate of net pay, use tax calculator.
Source: comozero.it
Article 1(237–238) of Italian Law No. 213/2023 does not apply indiscriminately to all cross-border workers. It covers: (a) Italian residents who work and stay in Switzerland and use the Italian SSN; (b) frontier workers under Article 9(1) of the Italy–Switzerland Agreement whose income is taxable only in Switzerland and who exercised the legal right to choose health insurance; and (c) dependants of those two categories. Paragraph 238 sets a progressive 3–6% share of net Swiss salary, with a €30 minimum and an ordinary €200 maximum for each month worked from 2024. The cap may be doubled in cases of omitted payment or omitted communication specified in Article 1(100) of Law No. 207/2024. The Region of residence sets the rates and procedure each year.
Frequently Asked Questions
- What are the main tax changes for border workers?
- In addition, there is a risk of losing 120 million for border municipalities. The New Frontier Agreement, signed on 23 December 2020, is in force from 1 January 2024, introducing new tax exemptions.
- How is double taxation for border workers managed?
- Income tax at source is only withheld in Switzerland. Italy avoids double taxation through the tax credit in the EC framework of model 730. It is critical not to confuse this mechanism with other issues such as health tax or refills, which are separate discussions. The Italy-Switzerland Double Taxation Convention has been in force since 9 March 1976, establishing the tax coordinates.
- What are the differences between old and new frontiersmen?
- The distinction is based on the date of July 17, 2023. Old cross-border workers remain taxed only in Switzerland (Art. 9 of the 2020 Agreement). For 'The Article 9 transitional regime applies only to workers who meet the Agreement’s definition and worked in Graubünden, Ticino or Valais between 31 December 2018 and 17 July 2023; covered employment income is taxable exclusively in Switzerland. The ordinary regime applies in other cases, with Italian taxation and credit for Swiss tax where applicable. The €10,000 in Article 4 of Law 83/2023 is only the income limit referred to in Article 1(175) of Law 147/2013, not a general allowance. FTA factsheet · Agreement, Article 9 · Normattiva, Article 4. This categorisation is crucial for the correct application of the tax regulations introduced with the New Frontier Agreement and for income management.
- What is meant by 'health tax' and what are its implications?
- The 'health tax' is a point of strong opposition between the Ticino, Swiss, Lombardy and Italian and Swiss trade unions. The unions argue that it is a tax, not a contribution. There is discussion of a possible blockage of refreshments, which would be considered a violation of the agreements. It is a separate issue from double taxation and transfers to border municipalities, which has different political and financial implications.
- What has emerged about border workers' salaries and privacy?
- The pre-filled income would have revealed protected data on the salaries of border workers, generating accusations of privacy violations and claims for compensation. A stock report indicates an increase of 5,500 francs in a year for the average salary in Switzerland, bringing it to 100,000. For the 'old frontier workers', an error in the data, an IRPEF alarm and the transmission of such data for the first time were cited, highlighting problems related to the management of salary information.
Related articles
- All articles: Border and customs
- Frontalieri: vendemmia a 15 franchi, tassa ingresso 4mila, 900 mln disoccupati
- Svizzera: tassa d'ingresso fino a 4mila franchi
- Tassa salute e ristorni: tavolo del 17 settembre a Berna
- Ristorni, dalla Svizzera rappresaglia contro Regione Lombardia: si ritiri subito la tassa sulla salute
- Tassa salute frontalieri: il Ticino boccia il prelievo